The blog that wants to go obsolete
Ah yes. Bike helmets. What are they? A simple piece of protective equipment? Or some ritual object which hopefully, after blessing it with the right incantations, will levitate you out of the way if a truck left hooks you? Or is this just the brain damage from this discussion speaking?
Not many things get cyclists up in arms as this simple object. And probably even cyclists who wear these things. Why is that?
Sad news arrived from Cambridgeshire, Great Britain. A cyclist lost balance and fell off the footpath. She then got run over by a car and died. Rest in piece.
Let me sketch a picture of what happened. An elderly cyclist was cycling on the footpath *1. She met a pedestrian coming on foot from the other side. That pedestrian got angry, some shouting and gesticulation ensued, and as the cyclist tried to get out of the way, she lost balance, and fell into the road. There, A car driver found himself in the wrong place at the wrong time and hit the cyclist.
The pedestrian got sentenced for three years in prison for this. Case closed? Eh, I think we still have to ask questions.
The previous post was about whether or not it is the right time to liberate the lane. One thing that was mentioned was that the average lane on the harbour bridge is used by about 10,000 people.
However not all lanes are created equal. How much capacity do we lose when switching to 7 lanes?
A prominent missing link for bicycling and walking in Auckland is the bridge over the Waitematā Harbour. About 10 years ago it was expected that Skypath would fill this gap — long story, but now, after another couple of somewhat dumb iterations, it looks like we will be without a cycle crossing for another while.
Some go as far as saying it is the most critical missing link in Auckland. But I think this is an exaggeration, seeing how the rest of the bicycle network on the North Shore basically doesn’t exit.
Paint-only bike lanes often cop a lot of flak. Sometimes for good reason, for instance the setup on Glenfield Road or Green Lane is ridiculous.
But still. When cycling in Auckland, most of the time, it is much worse than painted lanes. Are we throwing out the baby with the bathwater here?
So today we explore the abyss that lies below this level of infrastructure.
A while ago I filmed my ride from Birkenhead to Takapuna. You can do this ride mostly on quiet streets. Mostly, but not entirely.
Last time we saw our cycling route from Birkenhead to Takapuna, and saw how it is almost, but not quite there. Something like 90% there. So, is it 90% as good as 100% there?
Sadly, no.
The four types of cyclists
It is said that there’s 4 types of cyclists, roughly by level of confidence: The ‘Strong & Fearless’, the ‘Enthused & Confident’, The ‘Interested & Concerned’, and the ‘No Way, No How’. A study in Christchurch, New Zealand *1 gives following numbers:
E&CInterested & ConcernedNo wayThere are some that come up with 3 categories instead *2, but anyway, the majority of people is interested in cycling, but has a limited tolerance for risk taking.<1%7%60%33%
A few years ago I moved from Milford to Birkdale, and I have always felt that in Milford I could easily get around on a bicycle, whereas in Birkdale an acoustic bicycle is pretty much useless. It is really hilly.
So here I introduce the Bicycling Hill Misery Index, an estimate of how annoying hills are. A value of 0.0 means flat as a pancake. 1.0 means an area is so hilly that it doubles the effort required to go the same distance. By looking at the slopes of streets, we can put this on a map.
Every couple of months I come across some article or video saying that ‘no, hills aren’t harder than the flat’.
Said no cyclist ever.
Let’s imagine some guy called Daniel *1, Danny for friends. He is riding his bicycle to his local café, 3 km up the road. He can go two ways. One way is a bit shorter but it goes over a hill with a big 5% climb. Can you guess which way he is going to go?
You often hear talk about protected bicycle lanes. How we need them. How they will keep parked cars out. How we need them to fix left hooks. Spoiler alert: they won’t, and they won’t. Let’s try to clear up some misunderstanding.
You may remember this ad.
With a healthy portion of manufactured outrage. Hey, it is not allowed to ride a bike on the footpath. To this day I am not sure what their real problem was. zOMG they let a kid out unsupervised. Many people never miss a chance to pour scorn on parents.
Nevertheless there is talk of allowing cycling on the footpath. Officially you’re not allowed to do it, but a lot of people do it anyway. You’d be crazy to ride on the road.
So should the law catch up to the situation on the ground?
Ideally we shouldn’t ride on the footpath. Or, we shouldn’t have to. But, as is often the case, we will have to strike a balance between idealism and pragmatism.
Is it OK to settle for painted bike lanes? Often, people will say no. Cycling advocates will point out that it is not real infrastructure and they’ll point at the Netherlands. Authorities make this argument, and then conveniently figure out that therefore the cost will blow out and they’ll cancel the whole thing.
Surely the Dutch don’t bother with just paint, right?
Well, this is a myth.
I was recently introduced to the Wheeled Pedestrian blog. He is best described as a former cycling advocate. A bit disgruntled perhaps. He was lamenting the failure of cycling advocacy to achieve anything:
Progress will remain stalled while advocates fail to reflect on the reasons why they are failing. It is too convenient to blame AT. — @MarkBracey on twitter
I have made a dot map of cycling mode share a while ago. Now also on Observable. One dot for every quantum of 3 responses to the NZ Census. If you have a strong computer you can get an idea of the sheer difference in uptake between cycling and driving:
Sometimes the simplest of visualisations is the most bluntly clear. If we want cycling to be mainstream we have worse problems than just the lack of infrastructure.
Here are 2 somewhat related statements that sow division among urbanists:
If you see these coming up you can expect mockery. However, we have census data and the so-called deprivation index, so we can actually check this. Last time we saw little evidence that either of them is wrong.
Did anything change with the 2018 census?
Well, I called it:
So what is the catch with cycling for JAFA like me?
- Horrible cultural taboo, among people but especially within transport planning.
- Not getting cyclists killed is not a priority. Did I mention taboos? Here’s another one: decreasing the amount of on-street parking.
The ink is barely dry yet, and here we go: St Heliers village safety improvements — note the first two ‘improvements’ over the previous design:
The proposed improvements include:
- No loss of car parking.
- A new car parking area on Goldie Street.
After tinkering with these maps for a while, it struck me that the cycling mode share is low enough to visualise the census data directly.
At last, I made it onto the Northwestern Cycleway. It skirts the Northwestern Motorway all the way up to Henderson. Mostly. This cycleway made it to the news a couple of times this year. Let’s see what the fuss is about.
For me that first requires a ferry ride. Which is pretty limiting in the weekends — having Skypath built will make this a lot easier.
If you cross the Harbour Bridge to the north you touch down in Northcote Point
Or, perhaps more aptly, on Northcote Point. A sizeable part of the tip of what must once have been a quiet peninsula now looks like this:
And this thing is loud. Not just the usual traffic noise itself, but also the endless thuds of cars going over the seams between parts of the bridge. Somewhere nearby Skypath is meant to touch down, providing a bicycle link to the city across the harbour.
Dear New World Birkenhead,
I appreciate your effort to accomodate bicycles. But…
You don’t need a bicycle rack to hold your bike upright. You need it to lock your bicycle. This rack is too close to the wall to properly use a lock.
An argument often made against bicycling is that is only for the rich, and investment in bicycling infrastructure is thus a regressive measure. A casual glance at success stories seems to confirm this. Grey Lynn. Point Chevalier. Belmont. If you want to live there you and your significant other had better both get a 6 figure salary.
Is that impression correct? One way to get an idea is to look at census data. One of the questions asked is how you get to work. This is not a perfect measure (more local errands like shopping or going out are often more feasible on a bike than commuting), but it should give us an idea of where cycling is popular.